Discover the world with our lifehacks

Is a prior inconsistent statement admissible?

Is a prior inconsistent statement admissible?

Prior inconsistent statements are always admissible to impeach a witness, so long as they’re in fact inconsistent. Prior inconsistent statements are admissible for their truth only if given under oath at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding.

Can a prior inconsistent statement hearsay?

In the majority of U.S. jurisdictions, prior inconsistent statements may not be introduced to prove the truth of the prior statement itself, as this constitutes hearsay, but only to impeach the credibility of the witness.

How do you impeach a witness with a prior inconsistent statement?

First, the most basic step, is to have the witness repeat the testimony from today’s hearing that you want to impeach. You cannot effectively impeach unless the witness repeats a fact they said during the current hearing that clearly contradicts a prior statement.

What is the legal definition of a prior inconsistent statement?

Legal Definition of prior inconsistent statement : a witness’s statement made out of court prior to testifying that is inconsistent with the witness’s testimony and that may be offered to impeach the witness’s credibility — compare prior consistent statement.

What is an example of an inconsistent statement?

The topic of inconsistency is at the heart of logic. If you say, “Everyone left the room,” and I say, “John is someone who is still in the room,” then I’ve said something inconsistent with what you’ve said.

What is previous consistent statement?

In the law of evidence a previous consistent statement is a written or oral statement, made by a witness on some prior occasion to testifying, which is substantially similar to her testimony in court.

Which of the following is true about prior consistent statements?

Which of the following is true about prior consistent statements? They are generally not admissible to rehabilitate a witness.

What are three exceptions to the hearsay rule?

A statement of birth, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship by blood or marriage, or similar facts of personal or family history, contained in a regularly kept record of a religious organization.

What evidence can be used to impeach a witness?

Under common law, a witness may be impeached by proof the witness has contradicted him- or herself through evidence of prior acts or statements that are inconsistent with testimony given on direct examination.

What must be shown before a prior inconsistent statement can be introduced?

(b) Extrinsic Evidence of a Prior Inconsistent Statement. Extrinsic evidence of a witness’s prior inconsistent statement is admissible only if the witness is given an opportunity to explain or deny the statement and an adverse party is given an opportunity to examine the witness about it, or if justice so requires.

What are some types of inconsistency?

There are at least three types of inconsistency:

  • Forgotten or omitted information.
  • Additional information.
  • Contradictory information.

Can a prior inconsistent statement come in as substantive evidence?

Since this statement was not made under oath, it cannot come into the truth of the matter asserted, and plaintiff’s case will be dismissed. By contrast, under the law of Pennsylvania, this prior inconsistent statement would come in as substantive evidence.

Is a prior inconsistent statement hearsay?

When the prior inconsistent statement is one made by a defendant in a criminal case, it is covered by Rule 801 (d) (2). The House bill provides that a statement is not hearsay if the declarant testifies and is subject to cross-examination concerning the statement and the statement is one of identification of a person made after perceiving him.

When is a prior statement admissible in evidence?

The prior statement is consistent with the testimony given on the stand, and, if the opposite party wishes to open the door for its admission in evidence, no sound reason is apparent why it should not be received generally.

What to do if a witness gives a prior inconsistent statement?

Witness (a) Showing or Disclosing the Statement During Examination. When examining a witness about the witness’s prior statement, a party need not show it or disclose its contents to the witness. (b) Extrinsic Evidence of a Prior Inconsistent Statement.